3 Ways a Repeal of DOMA Would Benefit Same-Sex Couples

“[T]he Supreme Court announced that it has now scheduled all same-sex marriage cases currently pending before the Court for consideration at its November 20, 2012 scheduling conference. Those cases include eight petitions dealing directly with DOMA, one petition dealing with California’s ‘Proposition 8’ ban on same-sex marriage, and one petition dealing with an Arizona law similar to DOMA that restricts marital benefits for state workers solely to opposite-sex married couples.” (FordHarrison)
In recent months, two federal courts of appeal have ruled that the Defense of Marriage Age (DOMA) violates the U.S. Constitution, and the Supreme Court has announced that it will take on the issue.
What will change if DOMA is overturned? Here are three big-ticket items:
1. Tax breaks:
“There have been a number of cases that have declared that Section 3 of the Defense of Marriage Act is unconstitutional… In a recent FAQ, the IRS has indicated that it will continue to treat same-sex married couples as unmarried individuals for tax provisions that relate to marital status, regardless of these court decisions.” (Charles Rubin)
2. Employee benefits:
“The federal definition of spouse affects a variety of employee benefit and tax-related issues. For instance, certain retirement plans are required to provide Qualified Joint and Survivor Annuities or Qualified Pre-retirement Survivor Annuities to spouses (as defined under federal law). And while a non-federal government employer can extend coverage of a same-sex spouse under its group health plan, benefits may be taxable income to the employee because tax preferred status is only given to the participant’s spouse (as defined by federal law), and the participant’s dependent.” (FordHarrison)
3. Immigration status:
“… DOMA precludes immigration benefits from flowing to same-sex couples… Because of DOMA, there is no sponsorship option … under the ‘immediate relative’ category, which would compress the green card process to about six months. Pundits talk about the ‘line’ that immigrants need to join to embark on a ‘path to citizenship.’ Under the current system, same-sex couples are excluded from any line.” (Mintz Levin)
—-
Further reading on the Defense of Marriage Act and other challenges for same-sex couples:
- Second Circuit Finds DOMA Unconstitutional – FordHarrison
- First Circuit Holds DOMA Unconstitutional - Mintz Levin
- How The White House’s Endorsement of Same-Sex Marriage Affects Employment Law - Dinsmore & Shohl LLP
- Windsor Upheld - Charles (Chuck) Rubin
- Defense of Marriage Act Ruled Unconstitutional, Again - Lawyers.com
- Doma Still The Law, According To The IRS - Charles (Chuck) Rubin
- Non-Citizens in LGBT Marriages Avoid Deportation - Lawyers.com
- LGBT Couples Get Ripped Off by Estate Taxes - Lawyers.com
- DOMA Marriage Definition Struck Down By Another Lower Court - Charles (Chuck) Rubin
- Federal Estate Tax Equality for Same-Sex Couples - Duane Morris LLP
- Estate Tax Marital Deduction Allowed For Same-Sex Couple - Charles (Chuck) Rubin
- Opinion: Supreme Court Will Rule in Favor of Gay Marriage - Lawyers.com
- Legal Alert: First Circuit Finds the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) Unconstitutional – FordHarrison
- Appeals Court Rules Defense of Marriage Act Unconstitutional - Lawyers.com
- What You Need To Know About LGBT Divorce - Lawyers.com
—-
Find related law updates on JD Supra»